Teachable Moment? Descendants Dialogue: Slave & Slave Owner
I have a lot of LIFE occurring today & really, REALLY had not intended to post about the recent email exchange I’ve been having with a descendant from one of the lines that owned my ARNETT Ancestors.
Initially I’d contacted him {via email} because by happenstance, I’d discovered an online information resource that answered a few existing lineage questions & I felt, had the ability to answer several more.
Although cordial, the descendant expressed his desire not to “connect” the lines of research, citing previous issues with copyright & online resources yielding a profit from submitted historical content, the lack of his data being formally verified & his desire not to duplicate information already online.
He asked that I not publish the contents of a VERY informative email & out of respect to his request, I will not.
However, I cannot shake the dialogue nor the outcome — certainly the information he shared with me could be VITAL to a Genealogist researching Slave Ancestry from this Wilkes Co. line. Information that researcher may never come to know.
What I WILL publish is my emailed response to him.
I think it speaks clearly to my position {and certainly that of other African Ancestored Genealogists} & the challenges we face when encountering the descendants of our Ancestors slave owners.
My goal is not to embarrass him – to the contrary, I actually understand his position. My hope is that this a “teachable moment” that will better prepare us for future interactions of this sort & give us a broader view on how our personal histories can impact others.
My prayer – that we can all find a common ground around the issue of Slavery, because all of us – black, white, red or brown DESERVE to know our Ancestry & truth is, we need each other to aid us in this effort…
Luckie.
08.03.09
___________ – I do appreciate your taking time to explain in greater detail your views. I work in the Internet world and clearly understand the issues faced when posting historical family information online.
However, the issues you cite below are far broader than those faced by African Ancestored researchers.
First let me be clear – I yield no profit from any information published to my blog. My efforts are to assist other Wilkes County genealogists with moving their efforts forward. Publishing information is an Act of Kindness due to my understanding of the difficulties with pursuing this line of research.
Furthermore, I choose not to fight a loosing battle of restricting public access to online data. It’s the nature of the Internet, so I accept that if I choose to put material online, it very well may be borrowed. And honestly, in terms of my research, I have bigger fish to fry – I have an entire family history to recapture that was obliterated as a result of the US Chattel System.
For those of us researching slave ancestry, we don’t have the luxury of researching a plethora of data and then determining which pieces apply to our direct and/or indirect family lines.
We have challenges finding even a 3rd Grandparent and any effort to research further back than 1865 requires a willingness and openness to share on the part of the slave holders descendants.
If a descendant chooses not to be forthcoming with information, however minimal, then our progress is halted.
The information you hold on to, could make a HUGE difference in discovering who our Ancestors were and how they lived.
For __________, ___________ and myself, the interest is the ARNETT clan of Washington-Wilkes. I know there was an 1817 Petition re: the estate of John QUERNS that affected our family line greatly. We are merely attempting to determine how.
As I said in my previous email, it is certainly your right not to share your email with others and I will respect your request.
However, I am grateful that not all researchers feel the way you do because if they did, my lost family history would not stand a chance of being recovered, even in part.
Best,
Luckie.


