My, my, my… just when I was searching for a Tombstone Tuesday post, along came “Matt”, an OGR reader not at all happy about my recent Willie Lynch Letter 1712 post! I LOVE it!:-)
Why? Because though OGR has many followers — both black & white, who may have agreed and/or disagreed with the subject matter, few were willing to voice their opinion as Matt did. BRAVO Matt!:-)
Now, although Matt & I may differ in opinion, he poses several questions that warrant a response. For the most part, I will answer his questions in-line to his comments, so that folks can easily gauge the context of my response.
However, 1 question — in fact, the last one, I will call out here because I want my response to be CRYSTAL CLEAR:
How to do you sleep at night publishing a fake letter on your supposedly serious website ?
In two words Matt – VERY well! If the worst thing I can do is publish a letter, that at the very least, stimulates thoughts & opinions in respect to the Institution of Slavery in America, then I have actually accomplished my goal — TO MAKE PEOPLE THINK & NOT DISMISS, SLAVERY.
If not but for a moment, you for example, stopped to read on a subject matter that you normally wouldn’t consider — Slave Ancestry.
Then, you went a step further to research the history of Willie Lynch, albeit to be informed of or to dispel its truth.
And lastly, you felt strongly enough to write me & share your thoughts in a cordial manner. I appreciate that!
Truth is, we — black or white — don’t all HAVE to agree on EVERY given topic – not in life & certainly, not about Slavery, but at least we should be able to respectfully dialogue & share our opinions with one another, shouldn’t we?
You may see Our Georgia Roots as a “supposedly serious website”. I however, view it as my personal, historical, family blog to share my opionion about what I choose & for the most part, that centers around the impact of Slavery to my respective family & community.
I would encourage you Matt to visit/read more & to not be so quick to dismiss me due to 1 post regarding 1 man & 1 letter – real or not, that you personally disagree with.
This is the same “open mind” & objectivity that I have afforded you.
The floor is open!:-)
Luckie.
********************
Lucky -
I’m a white guy who is a genealogy junkie. My librarian in Athens sends out emails with links from time to time. I was check them out because they are always so good. I went to this site because I’m from GA, so “ourgeorgiaroots” obviously got my attention. Of course, I immediately saw that its a black genealogy site but me being a real junkie I wanted to see and appreciate your website. I was initially very impressed. You’ve put a tremendous amount of work into this and you’re doing a great service to all black researchers. I know it can be tough to research black lines for many reasons.
This thing about “Willie Lynch” really got my attention because I do a lot of reading and research in general and had never heard of the Willie Lynch letter. Now I know why. For the past few days I’ve read up on everything I can find on the subject. Youtube is a good source to get lots of different opinions from various black folks. The word hoax is probably used the most in describing the letter. I’m sure you’re aware of this because you are obviously a very serious researcher. I’m baffled as to why a serious person would post a fake letter of this nature on a site such as yours. [LD: I wouldn't call me a "serious person" per say, but an opinionated one for sure! Simply put, not intending to be rude -- it's my blog & I can post what I choose. For me, as a descendant of emancipated slaves, the context is completely relevant, whether the source (Willie Lynch) is or not.]
Even though this letter has been floating around for at least 15 years and has been roundly criticized as fake by black scholars from places like Spelman College, you still feel the need to perpetuate it ? Why ? What good does it do ? [LD: Should it make a difference to me if the scholar criticizing the WL text is black or white? Not really. Every person is entitled to his/her opinion -- I'd love to see someone trace LYNCH Genealogy to determine what it does and/or does not lend to. That is the way to put the debate to rest. Trace the bloodline & genealogy trail to see what shakes out.] Some black commentators on youtube contend that it doesn’t matter if the letter is fake. [LD: I agree, in the scheme of things, it doesn't. Willie Lynch could have been a real man or the embodiment of Slave psychology -- the process & outcome remain the same.] I find that very strange. I realize this fake letter isn’t for white consumption and I believe only a very tiny percentage of the white population would have ever heard of it. Its understandable that you all feel some need to “understand” the huge problems that plague the black community like black on black crime and the dissolution of the black nuclear family. I just fail to see how hand wringing over an obviously fake letter from a fake person is going to help. [LD: I'll be honest, I don't like the "you all" reference and/or any other generalizations AT ALL. Not all black people view history & present culture in the same light, nor should we. However, TRUE history speaks clearly to the core causes of black cultural struggle. Remove Willie Lynch & a letter -- it's still there. The dynamic of slavery was oppressive, dehumanizing & an acceptable modern day standard. Its policies reached FAR beyond the 1865 Emancipation, as did its ramifications. A good read to add more context to my argument -- Slavery by Another Name, by Douglas Blackmon.]
I asked a famous black author who I’ve known for a while to fill me in on this subject. She won’t even comment on it. I think she’s too embarrassed. [LD: Hmmm... how can I say this? At the core of the Willie Lynch letter is the psychology of the US Chattel System & reflective of how sick it truly was. We can debate Willie Lynch all day long, but can we deny the tactics outlined in the text? NO -- we can't, they existed then & unfortunately, exist now. If by dismissing the letter you feel relief to ignore what it speaks to, please don't. That said, neither I nor my Ancestors have reason to be embarrassed & neither should your friend -- if that is how she feels. The institution of slavery & the treatment of humans, by humans, was indeed shameful but to no fault of the Ancestors who endured it, or their descendants tasked with making sense of it.] I believe if she thought the letter was real she would not hesitate to defend it, and I believe if she was of the school who thinks “it doesn’t matter if its fake” she would have made that point. But she chooses to pretend it doesn’t exist in my opinion because its makes you all look bad. [LD: I beg to differ Matt -- by far, the Willie Lynch letter & America's slave history does not make "you all" {I'm assuming you mean African Americans?} look bad. To the contrary, it shines a light on the Ancestors who invoked, lived & profited from it & only makes them look bad.] How to do you sleep at night publishing a fake letter on your supposedly serious website? [LD: Asked & answered earlier.]